watched the much acclaimed `water' last night. nominated in the best foreign film category at the oscars this year, water is deepa mehta's third film after earth and fire.
based in 1938, in the midst of the national freedom struggle led by mahatma gandhi and his progressive ideas, water focuses on the struggles and lives of widows of various ages who are rehabilitated in an isolated ashram (supposedly in benares, india).
however, mehta could not shoot her film in benares, as there were many political and religious fundamentalists against her making this film, so she had to re-shoot with a fresh cast and crew in sri lanka.
in this film, she depicts widows having to undergo suffering and injustice above succumbing to the pressures of society while being shunned and insulted, used and degraded for no fault of theirs.
one wonders if society in india has changed at all from those earlier times. we constantly hear of women being treated badly and what about widows? it is a sin, their sin, that their husbands have died.
how does a 7-year old survive her husband who is 87 yrs of age? how does she not become a widow? why should she be treated like an outcast? and to think that she is only a child unaware of anything except maybe her dolls and other play things.
in bapsi sidhwa's book as in the movie, it is mentioned that `a woman is recognised as a person only when she is one with her husband. outside of marriage the wife has no recognized existence, so, when her husband dies, she should cease to exist.'
however, generally in india, did things change very much after the 1930's?
in `water' the child character, chuiya (played by sarla, a sri lankan) was hardly seven. does it still happen in our modern educated society?
i personally think it does especially in the remote villages in india. the mindset has not changed.
in the film, the widows owned no worldly possession, had their hair cut short, ate only one tasteless meal a day (no fried foods were allowed),wore the same sari which was basically a white piece of cloth, slept on the floor in dark cold rooms, begged for money outside temples and since the collections were usually meagre, they were forced into prostitution just to survive.
a beautiful film that exposes hypocrisy as a rich brahmin man (narayan's father in the film) who sleeps with these widows, justifies it `Our holy texts say brahmins can sleep with whomever they want, and the women they sleep with are blessed.'
`water' is about love, bonding, sacrifice, ignorance, education, customs, cultures, and women's issues.
it is about us viewers knowing and making a difference, or rather correcting an injustice occuring in the evil side of human society.
a must watch.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
Yes its a nice movie and it seems to have touched some raw chords in u.
Life and society always doesnt go the way we wish and desire and same way every society isnt what we expect.
Read The Arguementive Indian by Dr. Amrtya Sen , which would give you some better insight into the position of women.
What the movie has depicted is one shade, and there are many shades of it.
Society is dynamic organism and it keeps evolving and changing. we cant erase the label of being indians and its on individual levels we have to do what we feel is best......
BUT IN THE END YES THE MOVIE WILL TOUCH LOTOF RAW CHORDS.I HV SEEN NE SUCH ASHRAM IN MATHURA....AND MY THOUGHTS KEPT GOING BACK TO IT...
Strongly disagree with your review of the movie. While the subject matter is indeed of import, the treatment was pedestrian, even manipulative. Sorry, but this film is massively overrated. While the film is gorgeously shot and set, the script (and treatment) lacks soul and did not evoke any empathy from my end for the lead characters, a noteworthy performance from the little girl Chuhiya notwithstanding.
Hey my friend...
Indeed its' commendable on the analogy... i didn't happen to see WATER, though..
Roy, i do respect your thoughts, and certainly no one should face as your Mom did...don't want to feel bad for anything that happens to the hapless women in this world, and more specific to India..
All said and done, its' CAUSE & EFFECT. Since generations women have been subjugated (as they were let the men do it) b'cos they are physically weak or so.... mentally weak... I do agree that women have physical limitations, however, women, proven to have stronger minds than their counterparts... Had women used their minds well and protested...or better revolted...things wouldn't have gone this FAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRR..
Then, how on this earth women don't use their stronger minds, I guess its' in the GENES....
So, whats' the remedey....EDUCATION...
We, the so called educated, don't want to take the pain in making some positive changes to the society....If we need to impact the society with good changes, then we need to do things that are effective...things that are effective or not easy to do, but, not impossible.
Think,I don't want to bore... with my....
Rao....JNU, Mumbai
Definately bad movie i have ever seen.
I don't understand why she had to make this kind of movie, after all what Deepa Mehta had shown in the movie is totally wrong starting with the time period. Deepa needs to know the truth before she come up with an idea to make it.The way she had shown womens dressing up and just able to have a meal once in a day is totally wrong too. Her point is right but she don't seems like having a lot of knowledge about the culture, i just do not understand that if you do not know the culture and traditions very well why you make such kinds of movies????????????
Post a Comment